First on my list would be CASH, LOTS of it.
Second a new hybrid car (Or actually ANY new car)
Third, since we are dreaming here, a paid-for house where I don't have any repairs to make in a warmer place than where I am. The HGTV dream house is in Arizona this year...
A couple other things I always try for :
A Wii system with Wii fit.
A super duper whistles & bells laptop, Not because I need one, I can throw together a computer with donated parts. I just WANT ONE!
However I got two little surprise wins so far this year, so I am happy, and can still dream on.